Identity Alignment in Campaigning: Field-Experimental Evidence from Germany

Cinar, Asli Ceren; Ferié, Frederik; Foos, Florian

Abstract

Group identities, also known as social identities, have been established as measurable, stable, and behaviorally relevant constructs in marketing, psychology, and political science. According to research in political psychology, shared in-group identities can increase a voter’s support for an in-group political candidate. Consequently, messages emphasizing identity alignment with a candidate should successfully persuade voters to support the in-group candidate. However, most research focuses on one single group identity rather than various group identities. In addition, the impacts of identity alignment are often investigated in laboratory or survey settings. In this field experiment, we collaborated with a member of parliament running for re-election in a German state parliament in May 2022. We use postcards to recruit participants for a three-wave panel study, with the randomized controlled trial integrated into the panel study between the first and the second wave. We randomly allocate whether voters receive both contact on their doorstep and a handwritten postcard from the candidate. We also assign whether the postcard content stresses the candidate’s group identities. In addition to analyzing the impact of these stimuli on the voters’ evaluation of the candidate, we also look at their effect on the voters’ assessment of the candidate’s party. Our findings show that interaction with the candidate positively influences the candidate’s name recognition and favorability. Furthermore, highlighting her identities in postcards increases the candidate’s recognition, favorability, and votes. However, not in line with our hypotheses, the effect was not more pronounced among those who share her focal identities, nor did we find any supporting evidence of our treatment on party-level evaluations. We anticipate that future research in this area will benefit from our findings, which shed light on the impact of group identities and identity alignment on political persuasion.

Keywords

political marketing; group identities; social identities; identity alignment; voter behavior; field experiment; randomized controlled trial; panel study

Cite as

Cinar, A. C., Ferié, F., & Foos, F. (2023). Identity Alignment in Campaigning: Field-Experimental Evidence from Germany.

Details

Publication type
Abstract in edited proceedings (conference)

Peer reviewed
Yes

Publication status
Published

Year
2023

Conference
2023 Global Marketing Conference (GMC) at Seoul

Venue
Seoul

Book title
2023 Global Marketing Conference at Seoul Proceedings

Editor
Global Alliance of Marketing & Management Associations (GAMMA)

Start page
562

End page
562

Publisher
Selbstverlag / Eigenverlag

Place
Seoul

Language
English

ISSN
1976-8699

Full text