It’s Not Always Effective to Position Brands Against Large Competitors

Ferié, Frederik; Starke, Eliza

Abstract

The current research examines how rivalry between two focal brands spills over to consumers’ preferences for an uninvolved third-party brand. Whereas prior work has emphasized outcomes for the rival brands, little is known about effects on third-party brands that operate in the same market. Drawing on social identity and intergroup relations, we argue that rivalry creates a competition-centered narrative that heightens perceptions of the third brand’s external disadvantage, casting it as less likely to win. In a pre-registered study, we show that brand rivalry reduced purchase intentions for the third-party brand. The negative rivalry effect on brand’s 3 purchase intention is mediated by the increased perceived external disadvantage. Our findings challenge recommendations that brands with a small market share position themselves against market leaders. The theoretical implications of these findings are discussed, as are potential avenues for future studies within this project.

Keywords

brand rivalry; rivalry spillover effect; third-party brands

Cite as

Ferié, F., & Starke, E. (2026). It’s Not Always Effective to Position Brands Against Large Competitors.

Details

Publication type
Abstract in edited proceedings (conference)

Peer reviewed
Yes

Publication status
Published

Year
2026

Conference
European Marketing Academy (EMAC) 2026 Annual Conference

Venue
Bath

Volume
55th

Book title
Proceedings of the European Marketing Academy

Editor
European Marketing Academy (EMAC)

Start page
n.a.

End page
n.a.

Publisher
Selbstverlag / Eigenverlag

Place
Brussels

Language
English

ISSN
2709-1589

Full text